I got an email about a sale

KABUKI & NOH PERCUSSION <List price?
JAPANESE TAIKO PERCUSSION <where?

If only the Japanese Taiko was on sale, it’s been Ā£149 for ever…
I purhcased the decatoms, endless issues, shows 0 kits in bfd, can’t import the presets cos they are bfd2, app spins on authorising for hours on end, i thought we were over this shit.

These are some of the lowest prices I’ve ever seen. If only I waited until now and I could’ve saved a few hundred bucks.

1 Like

I grabbed Imperial and The Sabian Vault for not a lot of money.
WAY cheaper than all the original DVD versions i bought back in the day, they were NOT cheap!

I was a little underwhelmed with the Sabian Vault tbh. There are definitely a few nice and usable samples, but for some, the quality is more on par with the old BFD1 core cymbals, which isn’t very good. I got it for free, so I really shouldn’t complain. It’s just not an expansion I would personally recommend. If someone needed cymbals, I would tell them just to get Crush, or Dark Farm for their cymbals alone, as they’re newer and have better overall quality.

It all depends on what you do with them, the Crush and Dark farm packs aren’t really that good for Funk/Soul/Reggae etc and are geared more toward rock/metal…
Yes of course you can use any in any style, some just suit certain styles better, hence i picked up the Imperial expansion for the tighter rooms too… it ain’t all about HUGE compressed room mic channels for some of us. :wink:
I’m not particularly a fan of Zildjian cymbals, i used a mixed set of A, K and Z’s for a decade and a half many years ago when playing in various rock/alternative acts; but, i find the mid-range is just too angry for my ears and the styles i work in these days, i much prefer Istanbul/Bosphorus/Paiste/Sabian etc.

That’s fair… I just meant that the cymbals in those expansions are simply sampled better, so there’s a lot less midrange buildup and unpleasant resonances. The highs and sustain is much smoother, compared to others. I’ve noticed with older expansions that the hihats in particular can sound very boxy and have a very unrealistic sound and feel.

Again though, and i mean this in the spirit of understanding here, it’s about one’s needs stylistically.
What’s ā€˜boxy’ to one person is ā€˜tight’ to another. Some styles use cymbals that swell or ā€˜speak’ quicker and decay faster…
There are some things that seem to be ubiquitous in the rock world that some of us would NEVER entertain the idea of, an 1176 on a snare for instance, or crushing room mics as i mentioned before. Personally, i’m a fan of VCA compression for drum shells, usually with a limiter after to catch any peaks.
Imagine a really busy and subtle jazz drummer that’s performing some wonderful ghosting on his snare, now imagine giving that the same treatment you’d use on say a Nirvana track… gonna sound pretty shitty isn’t it. The snare would just dominate things as it would be so busy. Huge, crushed room mics would just make things even worse.
Whereas give Nico McBrain or large oilrig the same treatment, say from an Erykah Badu studio album, those drums are going to sound hilarious. You don’t tend to hear snare drums being run through spring reverbs too often in metal as you do in certain types of reggae.

It’s definitely a REALLY good thing to listen to and try techniques outside of one’s own musical preferences regularly, even if it’s to understand ā€˜why things are the way they are’ in different types of music.
On the flip side, it’s a great way of picking up things that might not have been tried in a certain style before… sometimes it’s for a good reason and sometimes it can work nicely.

From the current sale - even though I already have - sabian, percussion, orchestra, dark farm, retro, swan perc, metal & wood snares, Dunnett Ti, London, 8bit - would anyone recommend - I tend to not stick to a genre, really depends on mood, some might argue - progressive or alternative - I play guitar bass, keys, though I have programmed drums for years - bfd3 to me is the most realistic, I do have a couple of sonic reality kits on top of these - but whilst I say I’m not progressive - hardest thing to find is odd meter grooves that don’t sound like they only come from a Yes or Rush or Genesis composition, yes I can change them, but I don’t want to be doing a rehash based on a gorilla suit… lol…

So like, using an 1176 on a snare in a Jazz context? An 1176 will have a faster attack time than a VCA and sometimes more coloration, but it doesn’t mean that you have to always crush it and get that color. I tend to use a combination of both on the direct mics and then a VCA on the summing buss to even it out further. I don’t like using limiters on drum shells because it kills the transients. Clippers work much better at controlling the peaks without loosing the attack.

But yeah, what I said had nothing to do with drum shells or rooms, just the cymbals and how some of the older BFD ones just aren’t recorded very well. Not just the frequencies, but the attack being weird. But hey, we can disagree with our preferences and that’s ok.

Two of the most revered and legendary compressors, particularly for snare drum, are VCA compressors, the DBX 160 (particularly the earlier ā€˜VU’ model) and the DBX 165a. Great on toms too, but i like Distressors with their odd harmonics distortion. The slower attack is sort of the whole point with them. They’re millisecond rather than microsecond compressors. Remember the 1176 goes from 50-500 micro (millionths) of a second, whereas the DBX 160, which is prog dependant, is around 20-30 mili (thousands) of a second, that’s a MASSIVE difference.
The idea isn’t to catch every transient, rather to let them ā€˜breathe’ and to just catch the higher ones, so there’s’ dynamic range between them, if you follow?
The limiter on the 165a is particularly revered for its ability to distort in a pleasing way too.
A slower, VCA compressor actually lets MORE of the transient through by its very nature, so you use the makeup gain to bring the decay of the drum up.
You should try them out, if you want a snare that SMACKS like a wet fish being slapped against a wet plank, these things can hit HARD!
Use a 4:1 ratio with a DBX160, get about 10dB reduction and then back off the threshold to let more of the decay through. Use a limiter to just catch the louder peaks.
That’s a REALLY common way of compressing a snare outside of rock circles.

It’s the same with cymbals though dude, again i’m not being confrontational here, just that there are different styles that have different requirements, i personally liked the Sabian vault better than the Zildjian vault (which i might sell at some point as i rarely use it) as they sound ā€˜better’ for the genres i work in. They may not be recorded in such a way that’s suitable for your own needs, but for others they’re bang on.

It’s worth broadening one’s musical horizons outside one’s own preferred genres, it’s one of the ways more original music is created.

Peace! :folded_hands:

1 Like

Unsure if the conversation bypassed the request, but here’s hoping it didn’t …

Sorry dude, yeah this post got derailed (I’ll assume the blame).

Since I don’t see Horsepower listed, I highly recommend that one. It’s just a great sounding expansion and one of their best. Organic, fat with nice cymbals and ambient mics.

Oblivion is also excellent. Very lively and detailed kit. One of the snares is beautiful with nice overtones. It has one pure and two processed versions of each kit piece, including cymbals. Here’s a track I uploaded more recently, using Oblivion.

Vintage Recording Techniques I would say is another must-have. Big and punchy kick and detailed snare and nice cymbals. It has tons of ambient mics, allowing you to get really different mixes of the kit. I think Drew said it was their largest expansion.

Crush also became one of my favorite expansions. Super detailed and tight. The Meinl cymbals are some of BFD’s best sounding imo and this is another kit like Dark Farm that has extra HiHat artics. The toms are very unique, maybe not everyone’s cup of tea, as they could come across as maybe hollow, but they are very snappy, articulate and don’t have a lot of that low end mud.

For odd-time grooves, there’s really only the Dan Foord one. I have it, but haven’t really used it because I don’t do a lot of that type of stuff. You could maybe check out OddGrooves.

Cheers, I keep looking at the kits mentioned - did have Oblivion under the previous beta testing licence, and have considered the Vintage Recording, I don’t think I have enough hard drive space for Horsepower, but yeah wasn’t aware of the Dan Grooves, oddgrooves I have a few, but certain ones are a bit too odd, and whose gonna do a track in 27/11 …

You can always install expansions with a smaller footprint, albeit, with less detail. If it were me, I would find a way to make room for Horsepower on my drive… it’s that good.

Part of the size is because it has 3 versions like Oblivion. If you had enough room to just install it in full detail temporarily, you could keep say, the Pure version and just manually delete the processed version audio folders to save space.

Yeah, their grooves can be a bit too busy. Oddly enough, their latest freebie is a 4/4 jam based on a Rival Sons song. I’ve messaged them before about adding BFD3 mapping to their products, but he didn’t seem too motivated to do it. Their General MIDI mapping doesn’t really line up in BFD3. I suppose I could modify the map, but I just manually edit the data in my DAW to match the BFD 3.0 map, as that’s what I like to stick with most of the time.